Filtering out the AI ‘noise’AI is still in an adoption phase. Gimbel noted only 20% of firms are employing some form of AI in their operations. The share, though, is steadily growing.
A perplexing trend in the economic data has also caught the attention of policymakers. The economy expanded by 2.2% in 2025, even as overall hiring slowed to a trickle. That suggests U.S. workers are indeed becoming more productive even as fewer workers enter the labor market.
Most analysts, though, aren’t citing AI as the
culprit behind the trend. More point to the staggering investments committed to AI as a reason the U.S. economy has been able to keep robust growth. Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Meta all reported spending $131 billion in the first quarter of the year on AI development, and increased their AI expenditure forecasts for the year.
It will likely take many years for AI to deliver on broad-based increases in worker output. Take electricity, which began powering commercial grids in the 1880s. In the ensuing decades, construction developers built an electric grid and transmission lines to ensure widespread access. Factory floors were then redesigned, and workers retrained
to incorporate new electrical systems and procedures into their labor.
However, policymakers observe that AI isn’t something novel that popped up with the 2022 rollout of ChatGPT. What’s underway is another chapter stretching back to AI’s initial development in the mid-20th century.
“Should we expect a similar long period of access, adoption, learning, and transformation for AI? Maybe, but we are already well into it.” Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco President Mary Daly said in a February speech. “The origins of AI date back to the 1940s and ’50s, and it has evolved much like electricity did.”
Warsh has been counseled to tune out AI hype for now. During the confirmation hearing, Sen. John Kennedy of Louisiana memorably advised Warsh to tread carefully on AI.
“Here’s my worry — that a lot of this stuff about artificial intelligence making us more productive is a bunch of hype by people who want to sell stock and an IPO,” Kennedy said. “I'd be careful
there.”
Others echoed Kennedy. “I hope the Fed filters out all that noise,” Sen. Thom Tillis, another Republican member of the Senate Banking panel, told Quartz. “If they have empirical data that looks ahead and talks about the AI market expansion, capitalization of data centers... they can look at it, but it needs to be purely through an empirical lens, not through some sort of hype.”
It seems like AI is spreading like wildfire through the U.S. economy. But the people using it won’t reorganize
entire companies or their whole lives overnight.
“Some of the biggest AI boosters are holding [it] to an impossible standard for a new technology,” Gimbel said. “The technology may be fast. Humans are slow.”
—Joseph Zeballos-Roig
|