Local primary elections don’t normally command national attention, unless it’s New York City’s and a charismatic young lawmaker has just knocked off a member of the Democratic old guard. Wes Kosova is here with some takeaways. Plus: A mortgage fraud that stole Canadian homes and innovative loans for foreign MBA students. If this email was forwarded to you, click here to sign up. Stunning. Seismic. Momentous. Political reporters and pundits everywhere are scouring thesaurus.com today for adjectives expansive enough to capture the significance of Zohran Mamdani’s stunningly seismic and momentous defeat of Andrew Cuomo in Tuesday’s Democratic primary vote for New York mayor. A few months ago—heck, a few days ago—not many political pros would’ve confidently put money on Mamdani, a 33-year-old state assemblyman with a starter resume and a left-wing, eat-the-rich platform, against Cuomo, the tarnished but connected ex-governor who touted himself as the safe establishment pick after years of turmoil under Mayor Eric Adams. Mamdani, campaigning on Monday at a pizzeria in New York. Photographer: Adam Gray/Bloomberg What to make of Mamdani’s performance? It’s always hazardous to freight events with insta-meaning. Unfortunately, this is never a winning argument with magazine editors. (Ask me how I know.) So here’s a handful of initial thoughts about last night while we wait for the final vote tabulation and for a clearer picture to form in the days and weeks ahead. 1. The backlash against everything old is real. President Donald Trump’s MAGA supporters may revel in his nostalgic, back-to-the-future economic and social agenda. But for Democrats who still blame Joe Biden for overstaying his welcome and ushering Trump into the White House again (and Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg for not stepping down, and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi for keeping too tight a grip on rising stars in the party), there’s a deep and growing strain of resentment against what they see as spent figures pushing old, out-of-touch ideas and blocking the way for a new generation of leaders. The 67-year-old Cuomo, trying for a political comeback after sexual harassment allegations ended his time as New York governor, ran a by-the-book campaign the way it was done a decade ago, and a decade before that. He was backed by the city’s powerful and endorsed by former President Bill Clinton, another yesteryear politician brought low by sexual scandal. Meanwhile Mamdani staged a millennial campaign that was all about rejecting the way things have always been done. His proposals—free buses, free child care, rent control—were light on details (such as, how to pay for them), but full of ambition, exuberance and optimism. He was everywhere promoting them on social media and digital platforms, bypassing the traditional media gatekeepers to reach voters directly—and in a way that came across as authentic and natural, not manufactured by consultants. 2. The have-nots are fed up. New York has always been a place of the highest highs and the lowest lows, with a whole lot of people somewhere in the middle. But the vast chasm between the city’s poor and working classes and the rich and superrich has led to anger about how hard it is to afford living there, even among those who on paper are doing just fine. Mamdani, a democratic socialist, spoke directly to these concerns, vowing to tax millionaires and corporations, raise the minimum wage to $30 an hour, create city-owned grocery stores and invest in affordable housing. He drew a sharp contrast between himself and Cuomo, who was the preferred candidate of many executives. (Michael Bloomberg, the founder and majority owner of Businessweek parent Bloomberg LP, endorsed Cuomo). 3. Experience is a devalued currency. Not so long ago, a politician with just a few terms in the state assembly wouldn’t have gotten this far. But the value of expertise of all kinds is coming under scrutiny in American life. If Trump could be elected president without ever having held office, it’s no longer a stretch for many voters to consider giving an up-and-comer a shot at running a city. In a campaign debate, Cuomo tried to highlight Mamdani’s inexperience, saying it would be “reckless and dangerous” to elect him. Mamdani shot back, “I’ve never had to resign in disgrace.” * New York City is not a microcosm of America. Don’t be tempted to see Mamdani’s win as a sure sign of things to come in next year’s midterm congressional elections or the 2028 presidential campaign. Mamdani’s sharp criticism of Israel and his promises to resist Trump’s deportation of undocumented workers may have won him votes. And many of Mamdani supporters might have intended to send a message that they want Democrats in Washington to embrace more progressive policies. But: The desires of New York Democrats don’t necessarily mirror the views of most Americans, or even most Democrats. Some of the same campaign promises that delivered the day to Mamdani wouldn’t be warmly embraced by voters in a lot of other places—including independents in swing states who decided the last presidential election. Related: Mamdani’s Shock Win Has Wall Street Fretting Over ‘Hot Commie Summer’ |