Hi, it’s David Papadopoulos. Tune into NBC late Saturday afternoon and all will seem right in the world of horse racing. Cameras will pan across a sea of well-heeled dandies sipping mint juleps, puffing on Montecristos and clutching a fistful of gambling tickets. In all, some 150,000 people will squeeze into Churchill Downs to take in the Kentucky Derby. Millions more will watch on TV. Collectively, they’ll wager hundreds of millions of dollars. Churchill Downs Inc., the parent company, made record net revenue of $2.7 billion last year, along with record betting levels. The race itself attracted about 16.7 million viewers on NBC and Peacock, the most since 1989. And so too it goes at horse racing’s other fashionable venues — in Hot Springs, Arkansas, in the winter and Saratoga Springs, New York, in the summer and Lexington, Kentucky, in the fall, the game is thriving. This is a facade, though. The industry, as a whole, is withering away, and at a pace that suddenly seems to be quickening. Combined gambling volume at the country’s racetracks has sunk three years in a row, deepening a decline that began two decades ago, according to data compiled by the Jockey Club. It fell 0.9% in 2022, 3.7% in 2023 and 3.3% last year, leaving total annual volume at $11.3 billion, down from more than $15 billion in the early 2000s. This is at a time when betting in almost any other sport is booming. For all its high-stakes drama, horse racing is simply too slow and ritualistic for today’s 20-something-year-old gamblers. They far prefer the instantaneous dopamine hit they can get from online gambling sites spitting out a never-ending series of sports bets: Will the next pitch to Juan Soto be a ball or a strike? Will Jaylen Brown score the game’s first points? Will the 49ers win the pregame coin toss? Less gambling revenue for racetracks means less prize money for them to hand out to thoroughbred owners. Some tracks have inked revenue-sharing deals with local casinos to offset this problem, but the trend nationally is still grim. In inflation-adjusted terms, prize money has dropped more than 25% over the past 20 years. Without a stable purse structure, it’s hard to get owners to buy horses or breeders to breed them. Last year, they bred 18,000 thoroughbreds on all farms in the US, Canada and Puerto Rico, according to the Jockey Club. Back in the mid-1980s, that number would regularly surpass 50,000. The 150th running of the Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs in Louisville, Kentucky, on May 4. Photographer: Rob Carr/Getty Images Many tracks today are grappling with a horse shortage. There simply aren’t enough of them stabled on the grounds to fill up all the scheduled races. It’s a big reason why many run-down, small-town tracks have shuttered in recent years. It’s even a problem at some bigger venues like Santa Anita Park, an iconic spot nestled against the snow-capped mountains that ring Los Angeles. It was there in 2019 that the racing world sank into one of its deepest crises ever when horses started mysteriously dropping dead in large numbers. Animal-rights protests erupted, similar to the ones seen in the UK over the carnage in the Grand National each year, and calls to shut racing down in California grew louder. Track officials eventually managed to bring the fatality rate back down but the hit to Santa Anita’s image lingered — as has the struggle to fill its starting gates. So management gutted the schedule, limiting racing to just three days a week and capping the number of races at eight on most days. Still, a typical race there will lure a pitiful little band of contestants. Six is common. Seven or eight if they’re lucky. This is where the whole thing starts to feel like a vicious cycle. Gamblers don’t bet much money on races with small fields — they’re looking for the juicier payouts generated by races with lots of horses to pick from — and so track revenue sinks further, which in turn erodes prize money, which in turn stunts the breeding industry and on and on. Heck, even the marquee race of the year in Southern California, the Santa Anita Derby, only drew a field of five horses in early April. The winner that day was a strapping brown colt named Journalism. He’s stabled now in Louisville, where he figures to be the heavy favorite by the time the field of 19 horses weaves its way through the throngs of people and onto the track for the 151st running of the Kentucky Derby. Read More: |