HealthPlacebo Politics: Health Experts Concerned Over RFK Jr.'s New Vaccine Testing PlanWhat's going on: When RFK Jr. was confirmed as Health and Human Services Secretary, many doctors worried his history of anti-vaccine advocacy might influence his decisions. This week, some say, he’s proving them right. He not only made a misleading claim that the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine includes “aborted fetus debris,” but he also dropped a controversial new plan for vaccine testing. The proposed change? He wants all new vaccines to go through placebo trials — meaning some people would get vaxxed, while others would get an injection of a substance like saline (maybe you remember the Adele placebo scandal from Grey’s Anatomy). His team says the plan will increase transparency. But critics, including Dr. Paul Offit of the Vaccine Education Center at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, say it’s ethically fraught — and risks eroding public trust in vaccines. What it means: It’s unclear when or how RFK Jr.’s plan would be implemented — or what would be considered a “new” vaccine, since some, like the flu shot, are typically updated each year. While placebo testing is common for vaccines targeting new diseases, health experts say it doesn’t make sense for well-known illnesses like measles or polio, where effective vaccines already exist. In fact, some think it’s unethical because it could deny people a proven treatment while exposing them to serious illness. (One infamous example of unethical placebo use is the Tuskegee Experiment, in which researchers let Black men suffer from untreated syphilis for decades.) Meanwhile, the proposed change comes as measles outbreaks have hit Texas and other states, and public trust in vaccines continues to decline. Dr. Offit also says RFK Jr.’s plan could make it more arduous and expensive to produce vaccines like the COVID-19 booster, adding: “You are watching the gradual dissolution of the vaccine infrastructure in this country.” Related: A Second State Is About To Ban Fluoride in Public Drinking Water (The Guardian) |